Trump’s economic brand cracks wide open. Andrew Wilson points out that Trump’s approval on the economy sinks to 36%, that’s “worse than Biden’s were in his worst moments.” That collapse isn’t just about vibes — voters now say Trump’s policies themselves make the economy worse. The businessman persona he builds his politics on curdles into liability, as tariffs, attacks on the Fed, and wild swings in policy become impossible to spin away when people stare at higher bills in grocery aisles and at the pump. As Rick Wilson puts it, “He’s not just a symptom; he’s the cause.”
That shift in perception shows up in expectations. Inflation fears climb again, with half of Americans saying they expect a higher rate in the months ahead. Andrew frames it bluntly: Trump insists tariffs and cuts will fix the economy, “whereas now we’re seeing them as the problem.” The break between rhetoric and reality is exactly where opposition messaging presses hardest. “Cognitive dissonance is one of the most powerful tools we have to break people away from MAGA,” Andrew argues, and the polling suggests people already connect the dots.
Authoritarian overreach deepens the fracture. The Reuters/Ipsos survey finds majorities uneasy with Trump’s push to expand presidential power, and Rick stresses that “the authoritarian overreach is now creeping into the actual polling.” Deploying the military onto the streets of D.C. doesn’t read as a show of strength; it lands as weakness, desperation, and a government spinning out. That same erosion of confidence shows up in another place presidents can’t afford to lose it: their personal credibility.
Fewer than half of Americans trust what the White House says about Trump’s own health, with Democrats overwhelmingly disbelieving, independents split, and only Republicans offering real support. Andrew notes that once a president loses trust on something as basic as whether he is physically fit to lead, “people start questioning everything else they say.” When voters already doubt the numbers on the economy, the collapse of confidence in Trump’s health messaging adds another layer to the sense of a presidency adrift.
Nowhere is the damage clearer than Bucks County, Pennsylvania — the suburban bellwether Andrew calls “one of the swingiest parts of the country.” Trump is underwater there, with a 42% disapproval that spells trouble for Republican Rep. Brian Fitzpatrick’s reelection. As Rick recalls, voters once buy Trump’s “low tax, strong on crime” pitch because prices are stable. Now, with inflation biting and immigration policies cutting into households’ daily lives, “the persuasion matrix… is not in the Republicans’ favor right now.” For Democrats, health care and Medicare cuts remain potent levers, but the larger truth looks simpler: Trump drags down his own side.
Tune in to hear Rick and Andrew dissect why Trump’s economic collapse and creeping authoritarianism make him the weakest president heading into a midterm election in decades
