Can We Trust Gavin Newsom?

Let's parse the progressive record, corporate ties, and national ambitions of California's governor.

The governor of the Golden State has been both a liberal daydream and a convenient foil for the Trump regime. Gavin Newsom has always been primed for the national stage, but it’s only in Trump’s second term that he’s truly broken through the noise.

Newsom — and by extension, his press office — have been relentless. Their sarcasm and pointed critiques hit at nearly every White House move, foreign and domestic. They’ve gone further than soundbites, too, backing policy fights against blatant gerrymandering and calling out efforts to steal next year’s midterms with the help of Texas Governor Greg Abbott.

But with ties to big-money donors, a polished media persona, pro-Israel stances, and a fast-moving political history — is Newsom really the figure the next generation is ready to rally behind?

Too Early for Predictions

Gavin Newsom has always been a national figure in waiting, but it’s only amid battles with Trump that he’s become less background noise to party elites and more potential megaphone. His sarcastic memes mocking the president’s Truth Social habits and the high-profile protests in Los Angeles grabbed headlines — and even lifted his approval rating back from 38% to 56%.

Still, it’s far too early for any ‘28 announcements. And the bravado isn’t a free pass — 62% of Democrats want new leaders who talk less and serve the public more. His national primary polling lingers around 10-11%, while Kamala Harris stands around 26%. He polls stronger in California, but those are home-field numbers — not the real thing.

So yes: Newsom is ahead in the early innings, but we’ve still got a long way to go, and crowning him now walks a thin line between savvy spotlighting and an accidental coronation.

Confrontations with Trump

The governor isn’t just sniping Trump from the sidelines — he’s running a two-front war: meme-god trolling using Trump’s own style against hi, and formal actions (bills, FOIAs, legal threats) that force the White House to answer.

His press office has been posting in Trump’s all-caps cadence — short, taunting, and built for screenshots — to frame the redistricting fight as rigging vs. rules. By flipping Trump’s own tactics, Newsom disarms him of one of his most lethal weapons: control of the narrative.

Beyond social media, Newsom set up a California package designed to box in Texas. It redraws maps only if red states go first, a trap door that forces Abbott to choose between obeying his orange daddy or risk the midterms.

When heavily armed Border Patrol agents showed up outside a press conference in Los Angeles last week, Newsom didn’t cry foul — he filed a FOIA, demanding DHS emails that could prove political coordination. DHS denied it, but the point wasn’t the paperwork. It was showing that intimidation could be turned into a paper trail.

Same thing with the National Guard in Los Angeles. Newsom publicly demanded demobilization framing the federal deployment not as “law and order” but as a Trump distraction campaign dropped onto California soil.

What makes these fights stand out is how they blur the line between performance and policy — something Newsom has been doing long before sparring with a president.

Redistricting & Gerrymandering

Newsom’s biggest shot at Trump hasn’t been rhetorical, but structural. His redistricting plan highlights the contrast between California’s independent commission — designed to limit partisan capture — and Texas’ legislature-driven maps that all but guarantee Republican rule. Whether you see this as defending democracy or partisan cage fighting depends on how you read him: a governor protecting fairness, or a politician baiting his enemies into overplaying their hand.

His History

Newsom cut his teeth in San Francisco, where the politics can be just as ruthless. He made his name as a young mayor who legalized same-sex marriage before the country was ready. From there, he rose to lieutenant governor and eventually governor, selling himself as a progressive innovator but leaning heavily on real estate and Silicon Valley money.

His record has been mixed: strict COVID lockdowns paired with the infamous French Laundry dinner, ambitious housing plans undermined by affordability crises, and wildfire management that improved but never solved California’s vulnerabilities. He survived a recall election, but not without scars — reinforcing the image of a slick operator who sometimes lets performance overshadow policy.

Progressive Policies

On paper, Newsom has the resume: aggressive climate targets, green energy investments, and an expansion of Medi-Cal to cover undocumented immigrants. He’s signed bills boosting minimum wage and protecting labor rights.

But reality is uneven. California’s emissions remain stubborn, housing costs spiral, and homelessness persists despite billions in spending. The branding is pure progressive, but the outcomes show how hard it is to turn ambition into results when money and bureaucracy weigh down every decision.

Media & Podcast Presence

If politics is performance, Newsom is an Oscar contender. He doesn’t just show up on cable or use debates as viral stages — he built his own podcast to pump out a brand of politics designed for the digital age. The guest list has been controversial, with one booking drawing heavy fire: Charlie Kirk. Critics said it legitimized the gummy right-wing agitator whose politics cut against everything Newsom claims to stand for. Supporters countered that it showed a willingness to walk into hostile territory.

That’s the paradox of his media play. To progressives, he sells the fight — the slick liberal who will spar with DeSantis or tangle with Kirk on his own turf. To moderates, he sells stability — the polished communicator who seems comfortable in any room. His gift is packaging politics in a way that feels like both at once. His curse is that the polish sometimes reads as hollow, especially when the substance of those exchanges concerns working class survival and the cameras stop rolling

Corporate Ties

No one makes it to the top of California politics without money, and Newsom hasn’t tried to hide it. His campaigns have leaned on Silicon Valley, Hollywood, and real estate cash — making him look like a man of the moment but also raising questions about his loyalty should he ever make it to the White House.

For Democrats desperate for authenticity, those ties could be a crack in the facade — especially compared to national figures who built power from the ground up.

Verdict: Too Early to Tell

Gavin Newsom has the look, the voice, and the record of someone built for the national stage. He’s an effective communicator with progressive achievements and the polish of a national candidate. But with ties to big donors at a time when people want money out of politics, uneven results in California, and a trust gap outside his home state, he’s far from inevitable.

For now, he’s the loudest Democrat standing in Trump’s way. Whether that makes him the future of the party or just another polished figure passing through is a question only the next three years will answer.

Evan Fields is a veteran who writes the News from Underground Substack. Read the original article here.

---